SDG data protection blog

Laws & regulationIT security

KRITIS Evidence under Section 39 BSIG: Process and Deadlines

22 October 2026 by Sebastian Baier · Reading time approx. 10 minutes

Under Section 39 BSIG (the BSI Act), operators of critical facilities must demonstrate to the BSI (Federal Office for Information Security) every three years that they have implemented the measures under Sections 30 and 31 BSIG, by means of security audits, inspections or certifications. The BSI sets the date. The results, including all security deficiencies uncovered, must be submitted to the BSI. The audit under Section 39 BSIG replaces the former evidence under Section 8a (3) BSIG, which was due every two years.

This article shows how the audit works, which documents the BSI expects and how you can prepare. For an overview of all KRITIS obligations, see our page on KRITIS consulting.

What Section 39 BSIG requires

Provision Content
Subject matter (subs. 1 sentence 1) Implementation of the measures under Section 30 (1) sentence 1 in conjunction with Section 31 (1) and (2) sentence 1 BSIG, i.e. risk management, a higher level of protection and attack detection systems
Form (subs. 1 sentence 1) Security audits, inspections or certifications
Cycle (subs. 1 sentence 1) Every three years; the date is set by the BSI in consultation with the BBK (Federal Office of Civil Protection and Disaster Assistance)
Results (subs. 1 sentence 2) Submission to the BSI, including the security deficiencies uncovered
Powers of the BSI (subs. 1 sentences 3 to 5) Inspect documentation, require a plan for remedying deficiencies, require remediation, require evidence of remediation
Specifications by the BSI (subs. 2) Requirements for the way the audit is carried out, the suitability of the evidence and the auditing bodies, published on the BSI website
Exception (subs. 4) Does not apply to operators designated on the basis of Section 5 (7) KRITIS-Dachgesetz (the German critical infrastructure umbrella act)

The BSI has set out the requirements under subsection 2 in binding form in the "Grundsätzliche Anforderungen im Nachweisverfahren" (GAiN, the BSI's basic requirements for the evidence procedure), currently version 2.2 of 9 July 2026. In addition, there is the BSI's Orientierungshilfe zu Nachweisen (guidance on evidence) and the BSI FAQ.

Important

According to the BSI, the exceptions under Section 28 (5) and (6) BSIG, for example for telecommunications, energy under the EnWG and financial entities under DORA, only apply to the facilities that are actually subject to the sector-specific law, not to the operator as a whole. More on this in the article KRITIS and NIS2.

Deadlines and transition from the former Section 8a

  • 3 years cycle of the evidence under Section 39 (1) BSIG
  • 2 years cycle of the former evidence under Section 8a (3) BSIG
  • New operators: The first evidence is due no earlier than three years after the facility is first considered critical. The BSI communicates the date.
  • Existing KRITIS operators: The BSI sets the date no earlier than three years after the last evidence under the former Section 8a (3) BSIG (Section 39 (3)).
  • Transitional rule: If the evidence deadline would have expired within twelve months of entry into force, operators were still allowed to provide evidence under the previous rules. According to the BSI, the only choice was between the old and the new date; submission at any time within the year was not possible.
  • Subsequent deadlines: The next evidence is always due three years after the date communicated by the BSI. Submitting earlier does not shorten the subsequent deadline.

The BSI gives an example: if the BSI sets the date as 1 July 2027, the next evidence is due on 1 July 2030.

The operator is responsible for submitting on time, even if the auditing body is late. You should therefore plan in enough buffer.

Audit basis: B3S, ISO 27001 and certificates

The audit basis describes the requirements against which the audit is carried out. It is recorded in a separate document (annex PD.C).

Basis Note
Branchenspezifischer Sicherheitsstandard (B3S, industry-specific security standard) According to the GAiN, a B3S whose suitability has been confirmed by the BSI may not be the sole audit basis but may only be used in addition. It must be specified for the operator's actual facility
ISO/IEC 27001, also on the basis of IT-Grundschutz Can only be used under the conditions of the GAiN
C5 and other audit certificates Likewise only under the conditions of the GAiN
BSI Orientierungshilfe Deviations are permitted if equivalent alternatives are used

What a B3S is: Operators of critical facilities and their industry associations can propose industry-specific security standards that specify how the requirements under Section 30 (1) and Section 31 (1) and (2) BSIG are met. On application, the BSI confirms their suitability, in agreement with the BBK and the competent federal supervisory authority (Section 30 (9) in conjunction with (8) BSIG). There is no obligation to develop or apply a B3S. According to the BSI, however, anyone audited against a recognised B3S has legal certainty regarding the state of the art. The confirmations are valid for a limited period. Which B3S currently apply, for example for hospitals, pharmaceuticals, water or food retail, is shown in the BSI overview of B3S. Check there before the audit whether the B3S for your industry is still valid.

Twelve-month rule: At the start of the audit under Section 39 BSIG, the most recent underlying audit may not be older than twelve months. This also applies to ISO 27001, IT-Grundschutz and C5 evidence.

A certificate does not replace the audit under Section 39 BSIG. According to GAiN chapter 3.6, only basic requirements can be credited; KRITIS-specific requirements must be audited in addition. The implementation of each credited item must be documented in writing in the audit, and the ISO 27001 certificate must be submitted as well. The audit of the attack detection systems is always part of the evidence. Some GAiN requirements, including those on crediting certificates, only apply from 1 January 2027.

An ISMS based on ISO 27001 or on BSI IT-Grundschutz is nevertheless the best basis, because documentation, risk management and internal audits are already in place.

Auditing body and audit team

  • Suitable bodies: According to the Orientierungshilfe, certification bodies accredited by DAkkS (the German national accreditation body) are suitable. Accreditations by other national accreditation bodies in the EU are generally considered equivalent; if in doubt, ask the BSI.
  • Personnel certification: On 31 August 2026, the BSI announced a personnel certification for KRITIS auditors. Binding requirements for auditing bodies are expected to be added to the GAiN at the beginning of 2027. Ask your auditing body early on how it is preparing for this.
  • Independence and audit team (GAiN): The auditing body must be legally and economically independent of the operator; bodies affiliated within the same group are excluded. The audit team consists of at least two auditors, and key audit steps follow the four-eyes principle. The audit team lead changes after three evidence cycles at the latest.
  • Outsourcing: If data centre operations are outsourced (colocation), an on-site audit is generally required. The auditor always checks the management of service providers.

Process and documents to be submitted

  1. Define the scope Which critical facility, which IT systems, components and processes are relevant? (Annex PD.A)
  2. Define the audit basis Orientierungshilfe or an equivalent alternative, a B3S only in addition (annex PD.C)
  3. Appoint the auditing body It names the audit team.
  4. Carry out the audit Document review, interviews, samples and, if necessary, an on-site audit. There is no fixed sample size; the auditor documents scope and methodology.
  5. Prepare the audit report and list of deficiencies The list of deficiencies must be prepared with the current BSI Excel template and submitted in xls format.
  6. Submit the evidence Including evidence document P, the audit basis and the list of deficiencies. You only submit the audit report if requested. According to the BSI, form KI will be dropped on 1 January 2027.

The audit basis, scope and audit report may be written in English; all other parts must be in German. Always use the current templates from the BSI download page, as the documents are updated regularly.

Dealing with deficiencies

  • The evidence document must list all security deficiencies found in the audit.
  • Deficiencies may be remedied at any time. You document the remediation in an implementation plan; you can voluntarily report remedied deficiencies to the BSI.
  • The BSI can require a plan for remedying deficiencies, the remediation itself and evidence of it (Section 39 (1) sentences 3 to 5).
  • According to the BSI, risks generally cannot simply be accepted or transferred. The benchmark is the risk to the general public and proportionality under Section 31 (1) BSIG.

Independently of the evidence, the BSI can carry out its own in-depth audit (Tiefenprüfung) under Section 61 (5) BSIG, with or without a specific reason, in some cases on site. It is a separate procedure and not evidence.

How to prepare

  1. Know your date: Put the BSI evidence date in your calendar, with a buffer for the audit and submission.
  2. Appoint the auditing body early: Capacity is limited.
  3. Define the scope clearly: Record the relevant IT of the critical facility completely, including outsourced parts. How to do this is shown in the articles Scope in the KRITIS evidence and Network structure plan.
  4. Agree the audit basis: Orientierungshilfe, supplemented by the B3S for your industry if necessary, specified for your facility.
  5. Make attack detection systems demonstrable: Document logging, detection and response.
  6. Prepare for the RUN assessment: For audits ending after 1 April 2025, auditors rate seven topic areas with maturity and implementation levels. More in the article RUN: maturity and implementation levels.
  7. Work through open deficiencies from the last evidence and document their implementation.
  8. Dress rehearsal: an internal audit or friendly audit a few months before the audit.

How SDG supports you

  • Gap analysis against Sections 30 and 31 BSIG and the audit basis, including attack detection systems
  • Friendly audit as a dress rehearsal before the audit under Section 39 BSIG
  • Building or developing your ISMS based on ISO 27001 or IT-Grundschutz as the basis for evidence
  • Support with remedying deficiencies and the implementation plan
  • Penetration tests of your web applications, APIs and cloud environments: penetration test
  • External information security officer: external information security officer

The audit under Section 39 BSIG itself is carried out by an independent auditing body. We prepare you for it.

Frequently asked questions about KRITIS evidence

How often do KRITIS operators have to provide evidence?

Every three years under Section 39 (1) BSIG. The BSI sets the date and communicates the next date after each submission. Under the former law (Section 8a (3) BSIG), evidence was due every two years.

What has to be demonstrated?

The implementation of the measures under Section 30 (1) sentence 1 in conjunction with Section 31 (1) and (2) sentence 1 BSIG, i.e. risk management, a higher level of protection for the relevant IT and attack detection systems.

Is an ISO 27001 certificate sufficient as evidence?

No. According to GAiN chapter 3.6, certificates such as ISO 27001, IT-Grundschutz or C5 can only be credited for basic requirements; KRITIS-specific requirements must be audited in addition. At the start of the audit under Section 39 BSIG, the most recent underlying audit may not be older than twelve months. The audit of the attack detection systems is always part of the evidence.

Who may carry out the audit under Section 39 BSIG?

According to the BSI Orientierungshilfe, certification bodies accredited by DAkkS are suitable, and equivalent accreditations from other EU countries generally are too. The BSI has also announced a personnel certification for KRITIS auditors; binding requirements for auditing bodies are expected to follow at the beginning of 2027.

Which documents do I have to submit to the BSI?

Including evidence document P, the audit basis and the list of deficiencies in xls format based on the BSI template. You only submit the audit report if requested. The current templates on the BSI website are authoritative.

What happens to deficiencies that are found?

All deficiencies must be listed in the evidence. The BSI can require a plan for remedying deficiencies, the remediation itself and evidence of it. Deficiencies can be remedied at any time and the remediation voluntarily reported to the BSI.

What is an in-depth audit (Tiefenprüfung)?

A separate audit procedure of the BSI under Section 61 (5) BSIG, with or without a specific reason and in some cases on site. It is not evidence within the meaning of Section 39 BSIG.


Sources: Section 39 BSIG, BSI: FAQ on evidence, BSI: downloads for operators and auditors, BSI: Orientierungshilfe zu Nachweisen

Note: This article provides general information and does not replace legal advice in individual cases. The legal framework for KRITIS is in transition.